The Forgotten Schedule Of Condition: Dem-Master Demolition Ltd V Healthcare Environmental Services Limited
In the case of Dem-Master Demolition Limited v Healthcare Environmental Services Limited, the Outer House of the Court of Session considered an interesting question regarding the interpretation of a reference to a schedule of condition in a commercial lease. The tenant, Healthcare Environmental Services Limited, was obliged to maintain the property "in like condition as is evidenced on the Photographic Schedule…" However the schedule of condition was never prepared.
The court considered the question of what repairing standard should be imposed on the tenant at the termination of the lease. The landlord, Dem-Master Demolition Limited, argued that in the absence of the schedule of condition, the repairing obligation became unqualified, and the tenant was required to maintain the property in accordance with the “absolute” full repairing and insuring standard.
The court rejected the landlord’s argument and determined that the ordinary and natural meaning of the clause is that the tenant was obliged to restore the property to the condition that it was actually in at commencement of the lease. There was no requirement to improve the condition of the property beyond that standard. The omission to prepare the schedule of condition did not change the meaning of the repairing clause. Without the schedule of condition, both parties required to present other evidence to show the condition of the property at the date of entry.
The case serves as a useful reminder that landlords and tenants should ensure that schedules of condition are prepared timeously.
For more detailed commentary on the case please click here to read our briefing note. The briefing note originally appeared as an article by Laura Hay in the April 2017 edition of Property Law Bulletin, published by Thomson Reuters (Professional) UK Limited trading as W. Green.
19th May 2020
Do we really need an expensive base in city centres?
7th April 2020
Key principles for commercial landlords and tenants to consider when a lease is terminated.
3rd April 2020
A look at the new legislation in place to protect tenants.