The standard NEC dispute resolution provision which provides for disputes to be decided firstly by adjudication and then by a specified tribunal have been under closescrutiny by the Scottish appeal court in the case of The Fraserburgh Harbour Commissioners v McLaughlin & Harvey Limited, [2021] CSIH 58.
The pursuer raised court proceedings for damages in respect of certain defects in the works for the primary purpose of interrupting prescription (i.e. time bar) prior to any adjudication proceedings being commenced. There was no dispute between the parties that the defender was entitled to insist on its contractual right to have the merits of the matter determined by adjudication, and then arbitration, rather than the courts. However, the parties were in dispute as to what should happen to the court proceedings in the meantime: should they be sisted (i.e. paused) or dismissed?
You can read Chris Mackay and Andrew Little’s blog to find out why the court concluded it would sist the current court action pending the outcome of an adjudication and arbitration determining the merits of the dispute.
Related News, Insights & Events
Error.
No results.
Supreme Court overturns Court of Appeal on termination for repeated default under JCT contract
22/01/2026
In this article, we consider the Supreme Court’s decision overturning the Court of Appeal on contractor termination rights under clause 8.9 of the JCT Design and Build Contract.
The Scottish building safety levy: parliamentary approval amid industry concern
15/01/2026
Here, we discuss the Scottish Building Safety Levy and the practical and policy challenges highlighted during the Scottish Parliament’s recent debate.
Building safety principal designers and principal contractors – who does what?
13/01/2026
In this article, we discuss how post-Grenfell building safety reforms have reshaped the roles and responsibilities of principal designers and principal contractors.
{name}
{properties.pageSummary}
{properties.headline}
{properties.pageDate|date:dd/MM/yyyy}
{properties.shortDescription}
