The recent failed injunction attempt by David Walliams has all the ingredients of a conventional media-law story: a celebrity, serious allegations and an attempted injunction.

The approach taken, and what has followed, illustrates the wider lesson around the importance of deploying legal remedies only where they serve the reputational strategy, not simply because they are available.

A three-year investigation by The Guardian and ITV News reports allegations that Walliams used his celebrity status to pursue teenagers and young women. Walliams denies the allegations and says that he has not broken the law. An investigation has now been launched by the Metropolitan Police.

Before publication, he sought a permanent injunction. His lawyers relied on Articles 2 (right to life) and 3 (prohibition of torture) of the European Convention on Human Rights, arguing that publication created a serious risk to his life, alongside Article 8 privacy rights. After an expedited trial, the injunction was refused. The judge accepted a real and immediate risk to life but held that Articles 2 and 3 did not require the publication ban sought. The Article 8 claim also failed on the basis that no sufficient domestic legal basis for the injunction had been established and, in any event, the competing rights did not justify the restraint sought. Crucially, the court was not deciding whether the underlying allegations were true.

That distinction matters. Losing an injunction can quickly become conflated with losing on the facts. Legally, they are very different things. Reputationally, nuance is harder to convey.

The case has also re-ignited the wider debate: can deep pockets buy silence? That was not an issue the court was asked to determine in the Walliams case, but it sits within a growing debate about litigation which restricts public-interest reporting. Anti-SLAPP measures tackle ‘strategic lawsuits against public participation’: abusive litigation used to stifle public-interest scrutiny. In England and Wales, targeted statutory anti-SLAPP provisions now apply to claims relating to economic crime, alongside the courts’ existing case-management powers. The Scottish Government has said it is committed to taking action against SLAPPs and that it is considering proposals for legislation following consultation (though there is not yet a timeline proposed). However, seeking an injunction (or in Scotland, an interdict) does not in itself make a case a SLAPP. The challenge is to protect public-interest reporting without denying people a legitimate means of defending their privacy or reputation. 

For reputation management advisers and their clients, there is a separate question. Even where legal action is justified, what will it achieve? Of course, we do not know what advice Walliams received or whether he followed it.

An injunction may prevent tomorrow's headline. A defamation action may ultimately vindicate a pursuer. Neither necessarily answers the question businesses and individuals increasingly face: what will the public believe in the meantime?

The Walliams story illustrates the gap. The unsuccessful litigation itself became part of the story. Following publication, the BBC announced a review of material featuring Walliams and began removing some programmes. His literary agency confirmed it no longer represented him. Those decisions were taken upon his identity being made public, not after judicial findings on the allegations.

That is why effective reputation management is not simply a question of “can we stop this?”, but also “what happens if we try, what happens if we succeed, and what happens if we don't?”

Sometimes the most important advice in a reputation crisis is not about the remedy available, but about understanding the consequences of using it.

Written by

Pauline McCulloch

Pauline McCulloch

Director

Dispute Resolution

pauline.mcculloch@burnesspaull.com +44 (0)141 273 6791

Get in touch
Amy McSkimming

Amy McSkimming

Senior Solicitor

Intellectual Property

amy.mcskimming@burnesspaull.com +44 (0)131 473 6021

Get in touch

Related News, Insights & Events

Error.

No results.

Pre Action Disclosure What Is It And Can You Get It From An Overseas Party

Pre-action disclosure: what is it and can you get it from an overseas party?

06/11/2026

This article discusses pre-action disclosure, including the legal test, costs and challenges of obtaining documents from overseas parties.

Read more
Cyber Security Blog

Legal privilege should be part of every cyber incident response plan

18/09/2026

This blog discusses how legal privilege helps organisations obtain legal advice, manage cyber incidents and respond to potential regulatory scrutiny or claims.

Read more
Class Action

UPDATE: Scotland’s class action ‘opt out’ proposal

01/09/2026

This insight discusses the Scottish Civil Justice Council (SCJC) responses, which reveal a clear divergence of opinion.

Read more

Want to hear more from us?

Subscribe here Subscribe here