Summary:

The recent case of Destin Trading Inc (“Destin”) v Saipem SA (“Sapiem”) [2025] EWHC 668 (Ch) includes discussion in relation to the drafting of settlement agreements and, in particular, exclusive jurisdiction clauses.

Following a series of disputes between Destin and Siapem, the parties entered into a settlement agreement which provided that (i) the parties’ contract had come to an end and parties were released from any future claims arising out of the agreement; and (ii) the English courts had exclusive jurisdiction over any dispute arising out of the settlement agreement.

In 2024, Destin raised a claim again Saipem alleging that they had been induced into entering into the settlement agreement as a result of misrepresentations by Saipem. Destin sought rescission of the settlement agreement and claimed restitution and damages. Saipem applied to stay Destin’s monetary claims under the Arbitration Act 1996, arguing that the monetary claims arose under the original contract and were therefore subject to arbitration.

The Court refused the stay.

The Court held that the monetary claims were, in substance, claims for deceit and restitution arising from the settlement agreement. The governing dispute resolution clause was therefore that contained in the settlement agreement.

The Court applied the reasoning set out in Monde Petroleum SA v Westernzagros Ltd [2015] EWHC 67 (Comm) by analogy (notwithstanding that the Monde Case involved a termination agreement, as opposed to a settlement agreement). As a result, the Court concluded that when a settlement agreement is intended to bring earlier agreements (and related claims) to an end, and it contains a dispute resolution clause inconsistent with the underlying agreement, it will generally be construed as having a superseding or overriding effect.

Comment:

Jurisdiction clauses are often viewed as simply boiler plate. After spending what is likely to be significant time and expense in preparing a carefully crafted settlement agreement, it’s important that you consider the impact of your jurisdiction clause.

If the project is at a close, you may be content to amend the jurisdiction for any subsequent disputes which have not yet arisen – particularly if the defects period is over and you are at risk of time bar for any future claims.

However, if you resolve an interim dispute at an earlier stage, consider whether you are amending the jurisdiction provisions for only certain claims. You don’t want to end up in a situation where you are arguing about which proceedings apply, or different claims have to be resolved in different forms of proceedings.

Written by

Related News, Insights & Events

Error.

No results.

Construction & Projects Winter Seminar It's All About The Money Website

Construction & Projects Winter Seminar: It's All About The Money

19/11/2026


Join us for an in-person seminar as we explore the latest developments in insolvency, retention reform and payment practices and discuss practical steps businesses can take to protect their outcomes.

Read more
Why Payment Notice Deadlines Matter In Construction

The smash and grab lives on: why payment notice deadlines matter in construction

13/11/2026

Thirty years on, courts still apply Construction Act payment deadlines strictly. A notice served one day late is out of time, however sound the claim.

Read more
When A Valid Claim Isn't A Valid Notice Understanding Construction Payment Notices

When a valid claim isn't a valid notice: understanding construction payment notices

11/11/2026

This blog discusses how recent court decisions have clarified the requirements for valid payment notices.

Read more

Want to hear more from us?

Subscribe here Subscribe here