We use cookies to make your experience of our website better. Some of these are set by third party Google Analytics to help us analyse website traffic. To comply with privacy regulations, we require your consent to set these cookies. If you continue to use the site without selecting an option we will assume you are happy for us to use cookies.

What’s The Plan?

What’s The Plan?

“I love it when a plan comes together” – Colonel John “Hannibal” Smith, the A Team.

Like Hannibal Smith, the Scottish planning system also loves it when a plan comes together - it is a central tenant of our Planning system in this country that it operates what is referred to as a “plan led” system.  This principle, enshrined in statute, requires that all planning applications should be determined in accordance with the development plan unless there are other material reasons to come to a different decision.

Scotland operates a two tier plan approach, with Strategic Development Plans setting out a long term vision for development in the four city regions (Glasgow, Edinburgh, Aberdeen and Dundee) and individual local plans setting out more detailed policy and specific site allocations for each local authority area.

Local authorities are required to have a development plan in place at all times, and are expected to update their plans so that they are never more than 5 years old. However, this is easier said than done.
The identification of land for development in a local plan can have significant and long term implications for landowners, developers and the local community, and before they can adopt a new development plan, local authorities are required to undertake extensive consultation.

This consultation process takes time, and requires a significant commitment of resource by the local authority, and those who are trying to promote or prevent development. Following consultation, a planning Reporter, appointed by the Scottish Ministers, will undertake a public examination into the plan, and will, if necessary, recommend modifications.
Given all that is involved, it is no surprise that one of the most common gripes with the planning system is that development plans are too often out of date, and take too long to be updated.
A recent illustration of the difficulties in producing local plans is the City of Edinburgh Council’s attempts to produce an up to date Local Development Plan (LDP).

Last month, the Council signed off the final draft of its LDP, submitting it to Scottish Ministers for examination – a little over 2 years after the first draft of the LDP was issued for consultation.

Land identified in the draft LDP for development (particularly in West Edinburgh) has met with fierce local opposition, and Council members sent their draft plan to Ministers with less than a ringing endorsement – with one member describing it as “mince”. 

The Council do not expect their new LDP to be adopted until April 2016. In the meantime, Edinburgh’s current local plan is already over 5 years old, and its relevance to the decision making process is waning. This is particularly the case with housing development, where the Council accept that their current local plan does not identify enough land to meet the recognised housing need.

The need and demand for new housing does not wait for the local plan process, nor can or should it.

The Scottish Government’s principal planning policy document (SPP) sets out how planning applications should be considered where Local Plans are not up to date.  The SPP provides clear policy support for sustainable development. A number of recent planning appeal decisions illustrate how this policy should be applied to allow proposals that meet the sustainable development criteria to proceed.

Whilst up to date development plans are a key part of the Planning system, it is essential that delays in the preparation of plans are not allowed act as a brake on new development. 

Craig Whelton

This blog was originally published in The Scotsman on Monday 22 June 2015. A link to the article can be found here.